Republican senators publicly expressed confidence about retaining control of Congress, but polls and independent forecasters give Democrats strong odds to flip the House and a meaningful chance to win the Senate. Forecasts from Cook Political Report and FiveThirtyEight show Democrats leading in many battlegrounds, including several traditionally Republican states. Key questions for the final stretch include whether candidates should embrace President Trump and how voter anger over costs will shape outcomes.
Republicans' Midterm Optimism Clashes With Polling That Favors Democrats
On the one hand, Trump's approval rating is in the toilet, voters are very mad about affordability issues and Democratic candidates have the edge in GOP areas that nobody expected. On the other hand, who knows how the midterms will go! via Getty Images/via Associated Press
WASHINGTON — As the Senate paused its work until after the midterm elections, many Republican senators publicly projected confidence that their party will retain control of Congress — a posture that clashes with recent polls and independent forecasts pointing to Democratic gains.
GOP Confidence On The Record
Several GOP senators offered upbeat assessments as they left Capitol Hill. "I think we hold the majority of both chambers," Sen. Bernie Moreno (R-Ohio) told HuffPost. "Feeling good," said Sen. John Hoeven (R-N.D.), adding, "We're putting the right, long-term solutions on the table. We just need to get out and tell that story."
"The people of America don't want socialism," Hoeven said, reflecting a common Republican midterm argument.
Polls And Forecasters Paint A Different Picture
National analysts and nonpartisan trackers give Democrats the advantage, particularly in the race for the House. Historically, the president's party loses House seats in midterm elections, and Republicans currently hold a narrow 218–214 majority. The Cook Political Report forecasts Democrats will retake the House, estimating a net gain of roughly 5–15 seats. Nate Silver's FiveThirtyEight model assigns Democrats a roughly 93% chance of winning the House, projecting an average gain near 20 seats.
The Senate outlook is closer but still concerning for Republicans. Democrats would need to flip at least four seats to regain the majority, and forecasters note competitive contests in five states President Trump carried: Alaska, Iowa, Maine, Ohio and Texas. Cook's projects Democrats could net between one and five Senate seats. FiveThirtyEight gives Democrats about a 71% chance of flipping the Senate, with a five- to six-seat pickup as a likely outcome.
"This fealty test … could lead to our undoing," Sen. Thom Tillis (R-N.C.) said of his GOP colleagues needing to show independence from Trump. Tom Williams via Getty Images
Red-State Races To Watch
Several individual contests illustrate the shifting map. In Alaska, Democrat Mary Peltola has led GOP Sen. Dan Sullivan in some polls. In Ohio, Democrat Sherrod Brown has widened a lead against Republican Jon Husted in recent surveys. In Texas, Democratic state Rep. James Talarico has polled ahead of Republican Attorney General Ken Paxton in some matchups — a sign of surprising Democratic competitiveness in a traditionally red state.
Debate Over Tying Candidates To Trump
Republican leaders are divided over whether vulnerable nominees should embrace President Trump on the trail. The president has launched an intense campaign blitz, planning rallies with GOP candidates in tough races. Some senators — including Moreno and Sen. Jim Justice (R-W.Va.) — urged unity behind Trump, arguing that last-minute distancing would appear disingenuous.
"It doesn't matter until Election Day, and that's what matters," said Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-La.), downplaying concerns about Democratic inroads.
Others sounded cautions. Sen. Thom Tillis (R-N.C.) warned that strict loyalty tests could backfire: "This fealty test … could lead to our undoing," he said, adding that Trump should be welcomed in some states but avoided in others.
What Voters Say Matters
Beyond leadership debates, voters' chief grievances — particularly rising costs of living and fuel prices — figure centrally in the political dynamic. Several Republicans blamed media coverage for amplifying frustration, while acknowledging public anger about affordability is a dominant campaign issue.
Outlook
With control of the House widely expected to shift and the Senate genuinely competitive, the coming weeks will test the effectiveness of GOP messaging, the political impact of presidential campaigning, and whether polls hold as Election Day approaches.
Help us improve.
