Summary: Mary Peltola's Senate campaign has denied a New York Times report alleging a pattern of angry outbursts, slurs and staff turnover, saying the accounts exaggerate incidents that occurred while she grieved the 2023 deaths of her mother and husband. The Times based its story on interviews with nine former staffers and contemporaneous messages and photos; some ex-aides disputed the paper's characterization while others praised Peltola. Polling shows a tight Alaska race — Cook Political Report calls it a toss-up — and commentators and markets reacted briefly to the report.
Peltola Campaign Denies NYT Allegations of Outbursts and Slurs, Cites Grief After 2023 Losses
Mary Peltola fields a question during a televised debate on October 10, 2024, in Anchorage, Alaska. (Bill Roth/Anchorage Daily News via AP, File)
Mary Peltola's U.S. Senate campaign has strongly rejected a New York Times report that former staffers described a pattern of angry outbursts, profane language and staff turnover. The campaign says the accounts overstate isolated incidents that occurred while Peltola was grieving the deaths of her mother and husband in 2023.
The Times story, based on interviews with nine former staff members and contemporaneous text messages and photos, included allegations that Peltola used slurs, berated staff and, in one 2024 episode, shoved an aide. Peltola's campaign disputed several of those claims, calling some accounts inaccurate and characterizing others as exaggerated moments tied to a difficult period in her life.
Campaign Response: Spokesman Harry Child told reporters the piece ‘‘exaggerates and outright lies about moments from the hardest period of her life, and falsely presents them as a pattern of behavior.’’ The campaign acknowledged Peltola struggled while grieving the deaths of her mother and her husband, Eugene Peltola Jr., who died in a plane crash in September 2023, and said she treats staff with ‘‘respect and care.’’
Accusations and Context: While several former aides described negative episodes to the Times, others offered positive recollections; one former aide called Peltola ‘‘one of the finest human beings’’ he had worked for. The article also reported an internal campaign shake-up in August over disagreements about signage and messaging that led to changes among senior staff and consultants.
Key sourcing for the story included anonymous interviews with nine former staff members and a review of text messages and photos contemporaneous with the alleged incidents.
Political Stakes and Reactions: The Alaska Senate race is being watched nationally: Cook Political Report rates it a toss-up as Democrats aim to flip control of the Senate. Recent polling shows a competitive contest. An AARP survey released Sept. 17 found Peltola ahead of incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan 46% to 41% in the initial round and 53% to 47% in a ranked-choice simulation. Other polls show a narrow margin either way, and analysts warn Alaska is difficult to poll reliably due to its geography and diverse electorate.
Prominent commentators reacted to the Times piece: polling analyst Nate Silver questioned the story's framing on X, suggesting many readers might feel sympathy for Peltola. Markets briefly moved: Kalshi's prediction market showed Peltola's probability dip from about 77% to 72% on the day the report appeared.
Bottom Line: The campaign rejects the portrayal of sustained abusive behavior and emphasizes Peltola's policy priorities, including lowering costs and putting Alaska first. The competing accounts — anonymous former staffers, contemporaneous messages cited by the Times, and the campaign's rebuttals — leave voters weighing both personal conduct allegations and the policy stakes in a close, nationally significant race.
Help us improve.
