Stanford removed campus dining banners after generative AI was used to erase student Billy Ramirez from a 2024 Lunar New Year photo and insert a generated woman. The two remaining students were also digitally altered and have filed a Title VI complaint alleging discrimination. Stanford confirmed the edits violated its AI and communications policies, removed the banners, and said it will increase staff training and tighten review procedures. The incident has prompted debate about authentic representation versus manufactured diversity on campus.
Stanford Pulls Dining Banners After AI Replaces Latino Student With Generated Black Woman
Image Credit: The Stanford Review.
Stanford University removed promotional dining banners from campus after acknowledging that its Residential & Dining Enterprises department used generative AI to alter a photograph, erasing a Latino student and inserting a generated woman.
The original image, taken at a 2024 Lunar New Year dinner, showed student Billy Ramirez and two classmates holding plates of food. When the photo later appeared on fall advertising banners for Stanford's dining services, Ramirez was missing — replaced by a woman who had not been in the original shot — and the other two students' faces and clothing were noticeably changed.
How the edits were discovered
Ramirez said a friend sent him a side-by-side comparison of the banner and the original photo while he was traveling back to campus. At first he laughed, but he quickly realized the edits were not simple touch-ups or background swaps: "Seeing my identity changed and being left out of the picture made me feel, in a way, silenced and erased," he told the Stanford Review.
"Seeing my identity changed and being left out of the picture made me feel, in a way, silenced and erased." — Billy Ramirez
University response and policy
Stanford confirmed that Residential & Dining Enterprises used generative AI on the photo and said the alterations violated campus policy. University public relations director Charlene Gage told The Stanford Daily that the image had been altered "in violation of university policy," adding: "Both the alteration and lack of disclosure in this case violate that policy." The banners were taken down and the university said it would provide additional staff training and strengthen review procedures for marketing materials.
Impact on other students and complaints
The Stanford Daily reported that both other students in the photo were also edited: their faces were slimmed and facial features and clothing were modified (in one case to include Stanford-branded apparel). Those students said they were embarrassed by edits to their ethnic facial features and have filed a Title VI complaint alleging discrimination; they asked to remain anonymous, citing ongoing harassment.
Broader debate about representation
The episode has reignited discussion about authentic representation versus manufactured diversity. Ramirez and other students argued the university should examine and address real campus representation rather than fabricating it. Stanford freshman Kavinder Patel told ABC News: "They have diversity and they shouldn't need to fabricate it."
Ramirez said the unexpected national attention left him exhausted: "I don't want my legacy at Stanford to be 'the AI guy,'" he told The Stanford Daily.
What’s next: Stanford removed the banners, affirmed the edits violated AI and communications guidelines, and pledged additional staff training and stronger review procedures to prevent similar incidents.
Help us improve.
