Amir Hassan, a Trump-endorsed Republican, was defeated in Michigan’s 8th District primary by Thomas Smith, who had withdrawn from the race but remained on the ballot. Hassan received 33.2% of the vote to Smith’s 50.4%, losing by more than 10,000 votes despite a public endorsement from President Trump. The result raises questions about Trump’s influence in local GOP contests and underscores concerns about campaign strength and voter attitudes toward candidate identity.
Trump-Backed Candidate Amir Hassan Loses Primary to Withdrawn Opponent, Raising Questions About GOP Influence
Trump Humiliated as His Candidate Loses to Someone Who Dropped Out
President Trump’s handpicked Republican for Michigan’s 8th Congressional District primary, Amir Hassan, suffered a decisive defeat to Thomas Smith — a contender who had withdrawn from the race weeks earlier but whose name remained on the ballot.
Trump publicly endorsed Hassan on Truth Social days before the primary: "Amir Hassan has my Complete and Total Endorsement to be the next Representative from Michigan's 8th Congressional District. Election Day is Tuesday, August 4th. GET OUT AND VOTE FOR AMIR—HE WILL NEVER LET YOU DOWN!"
Despite that high-profile backing, Hassan received just 33.2 percent of the vote compared with Smith’s 50.4 percent, losing by more than 10,000 votes, according to results reported by The Detroit News. Smith had formally suspended his campaign the previous month and ceased active campaigning, but his name still appeared on the ballot.
Campaign Context and Controversy
Hassan, a military veteran who calls himself an "America First Patriot," faced criticism from some MAGA-aligned voters who raised concerns about his perceived background based on his name. Hassan has stated that he identifies as a Christian, has condemned extremists who "pervert Islam into something evil," and has emphasized his support for Israel as a close U.S. ally.
Analysts say the result could reflect a mix of factors: local voter preferences, the oddity of a withdrawn candidate winning ballot support, questions about Hassan’s campaign strength, and possible identity-based bias among some primary voters. The margin suggests that Trump’s endorsement did not carry enough weight in this contest to overcome those dynamics.
What Comes Next
Thomas Smith, the primary winner, will nominally advance to the general election to face Democratic Representative Kristen McDonald Rivet, who ran unopposed in her primary. It remains uncertain whether Smith will actively campaign in the general election; he had previously endorsed another candidate, Al Lemmo, who captured only 16.4 percent of the primary vote.
Why it matters: The upset highlights limits to presidential endorsements in down-ballot races and underscores ongoing tensions within the GOP over identity, electability and local dynamics.
Help us improve.
