The article argues that President Trump’s weak job and personal ratings — highlighted in a recent YouGov/The Economist poll — create an opening for Democrats, but negatives alone won’t win elections. Key poll findings: 54% distrust his handling of the economy, while only 28% trust him a lot. Democrats should combine this critique with a positive, promise‑keeping message that emphasizes achievements like Social Security, Medicare, the Affordable Care Act and civil‑rights protections to persuade independents and weak partisans.
Turn Trump’s Unpopularity Into A Midterm Advantage: A Practical Democratic Playbook
President Donald Trump’s poor job and personal ratings provide Democrats with a powerful foundation for a midterm message — but negatives alone won’t win elections. To convert broad dissatisfaction into votes, Democrats must pair Trump-focused critiques with a clear, promise‑keeping alternative voters can trust.
A national tracking poll last week for The Economist by YouGov underscores the challenge and the opportunity. Respondents were asked whether they trusted the president “a lot,” “a little” or “not at all” across more than 20 policy areas. On none of those issues did a majority say they trusted him “a lot.”
Economy And Personal Ratings: A Troubling Mix For Trump
Inflation remains voters’ top concern. A majority — 54 percent — say they do not trust Trump’s handling of the economy at all; 28 percent say they trust him a lot and 18 percent say they trust him a little. Because many voters prioritize pocketbook issues, those numbers are politically consequential.
On personal traits, Trump fares even worse. Roughly two in three respondents say the word "arrogant" describes him "a lot," and majorities also characterize him as "reckless," "dishonest," and "corrupt." These personal negatives can be especially influential among independents and weak partisans who weigh character heavily when choosing candidates.
From Negatives To A Winning Message
Job ratings and unfavorable traits create political headwinds for Trump and his allies, but Democrats must do more than point and recoil. The most effective campaign message combines a clear critique with a positive alternative that demonstrates competence and results.
Key line of attack: Remind voters that Trump promised to reduce prices “starting on day one” of a second term — a promise unmet as many essentials have risen sharply.
Recent price trends amplify that argument: reports indicate unleaded gasoline prices have risen sharply (nearly doubling in the referenced timeframe), and many grocery staples — including ground beef and orange juice — have climbed significantly, striking directly at household budgets.
National generic-ballot surveys still show Democrats leading head-to-head, but that advantage does not fully capitalize on the scale of Trump’s negatives. To close that gap, Democrats should showcase a credible, promise‑keeping agenda that contrasts with the president’s record and his allies’ priorities.
Lean On Delivery, Not Just Criticism
Democrats should emphasize their record of delivering long-standing commitments to families: Social Security, Medicare, the Affordable Care Act and civil‑rights legislation are concrete examples of promises fulfilled. Framing those achievements as evidence of reliability and protection against rollback gives voters a reason to prefer Democrats beyond mere opposition to Trump.
Ultimately, the most persuasive midterm message will pair Trump-focused accountability with an affirmative pitch: show how Democratic policy preserves and improves Americans’ lives and contrast that with the president’s broken promises and troubling personal ratings.
Brad Bannon is a national Democratic strategist and CEO of Bannon Communications. He writes weekly for The Hill and hosts the progressive podcast Deadline D.C. with Brad Bannon.
Help us improve.
