Bodycam footage from a May 21 traffic stop in Shenandoah, Texas, shows Elizabeth Kim repeatedly telling deputies she was "so scared" and asking for a female officer before she was handcuffed and charged with interfering with public duties and resisting arrest. The stop began over a missing turn signal and a dim license plate light and has drawn split reactions online about who escalated the encounter. A retired HPD captain called the deputy’s approach unusual and said he did not see probable cause for the arrest, though that opinion has not been legally tested. The sheriff’s office has been asked for comment and a records request was forwarded to the Texas Attorney General’s Office.
Woman Says She Was 'So Scared' During Texas Traffic Stop That Led To Arrest — Bodycam Footage Divides Viewers
Photo KPRC 2 Click2Houston / YouTube
A routine traffic stop in Shenandoah, Texas, on May 21 produced emotional body-worn camera footage after 40-year-old Elizabeth Kim repeatedly pleaded that she was "so scared" and asked for a female officer before deputies handcuffed her and arrested her on misdemeanor charges.
What Happened
According to KPRC 2, a Montgomery County Sheriff's deputy pulled Kim over around 9:30 p.m. on Interstate 45 for failing to use a turn signal and for a dim license plate light. The bodycam video shows the deputy issuing loud verbal commands from a distance rather than first approaching Kim’s window; about four minutes into the encounter the deputy walked to the passenger-side window to identify himself and explain the reason for the stop.
Bodycam Details
The recording captures Kim repeatedly telling deputies she was frightened, asking for a female officer and calling her mother. She eventually exited the vehicle, continued her phone call, and was then placed in handcuffs. Kim was charged with interfering with public duties and resisting arrest. After the arrest she showed the station bruising on her inner thighs that she said resulted from the encounter.
Legal Context
U.S. Supreme Court precedent generally permits officers to order drivers out of a vehicle during a lawful traffic stop and allows a limited pat-down for weapons when officers have reasonable suspicion that a person may be armed and dangerous. That framework does not automatically validate every search or arrest; whether the deputy's actions in this case were lawful remains unresolved and could be subject to internal review or legal challenge.
Expert Reaction and Public Debate
Dr. Greg Fremin, a retired Houston Police Department captain with 34 years of experience, told KPRC 2 he found the deputy’s approach "highly unusual" for what began as a minor traffic violation and said, in his view, the stop escalated unnecessarily and he did not see probable cause for the arrest. That is a professional opinion and has not been validated by a court.
Online viewers largely split into three camps: those who said drivers should comply with lawful orders and pursue complaints later; those who criticized the deputy for ordering Kim out from a distance before explaining the stop; and those who blamed both Kim’s panic and the deputy’s communication style for escalating the encounter.
Follow-Up
KPRC 2 reported it contacted the Montgomery County Sheriff’s Office, which said it would consult appropriate command staff and respond. The station also requested the deputy’s personnel records; the sheriff’s office forwarded that request to the Texas Attorney General’s Office for an opinion on release. The sheriff’s office had not confirmed whether the deputy was the subject of an internal investigation at the time of publication.
Note: The body-worn camera video circulated online in edited clips; several commenters asked to see the complete, unedited footage before drawing final conclusions.
Help us improve.
