The EPA has reopened public comment on a revived 2020 plan to create federal permits for coal ash disposal, drawing criticism for provisions dubbed "permits for life." Advocates warn these changes could reduce safeguards for communities near coal plants and shift enforcement responsibility from regulators to industry. Earthjustice and partner groups say the proposal, together with an April rule, signals a broader rollback of federal oversight and are mobilizing to oppose it.
EPA Reopens Federal Coal Ash Permit Plan; Critics Warn 'Permits for Life' Could Weaken Oversight
Photo Credit: iStock
The Environmental Protection Agency has reopened public comment on a revived 2020 proposal to create federal permits for coal ash disposal — a move critics say includes provisions so permissive they amount to "permits for life." Environmental and community groups warn the change could reduce protections for people living near coal-fired plants and shift enforcement responsibilities from regulators to industry.
Background
Coal ash is the toxic residue left after coal is burned to generate electricity. It contains hazardous pollutants that can leach into groundwater and nearby waterways when disposal sites are poorly monitored or not properly remediated. Contamination from coal ash has been documented at many current and former U.S. coal plant sites.
What the Proposal Would Do
The reopened proposal seeks to establish a federal permitting framework for coal ash disposal. Critics say key elements — including long-term or effectively permanent permits often described as "permits for life," and broad "general permits" — could allow companies to self-determine eligibility and reduce the frequency or rigor of regulatory review.
Concerns From Advocates
Environmental advocates, led by groups such as Earthjustice, argue that the proposal would weaken federal oversight and create uneven protections across states. Earthjustice attorney Gavin Kearney says this action, coupled with another EPA proposal announced in April, points to a broader rollback of federal enforcement that could leave communities with fewer safeguards and longer fights to secure monitoring and cleanup.
Community Impacts
For families living near coal plants, weaker permitting and oversight mean prolonged uncertainty over local water safety, potential declines in property values, and greater long-term health risks. A less rigorous system could force communities into lengthy, site-by-site disputes rather than providing clear, nationwide baseline protections.
Next Steps
The EPA has invited public comment on the proposal. Environmental groups have publicly condemned the approach and indicated they will mobilize to oppose changes they believe roll back protections for communities near coal ash dumps. Stakeholders and residents can submit input during the comment period to influence the final decision.
Bottom line: The reopened rulemaking could reshape how coal ash is regulated nationwide — with potentially lasting consequences for public health and environmental oversight.
Help us improve.
