Federal prosecutors asked a Miami court to keep Andrew and Tristan Tate detained during extradition proceedings, arguing the brothers' own social media posts show they pose flight risks and a danger to the community. The filing cites videos and posts in which Andrew claims to hold multiple passports and driver's licenses and declares he is "above the law" and "never getting extradited." Prosecutors also rebutted the Tates' complaints about detention conditions with commissary receipts and descriptions of recreation and attorney access. The request arrives as British authorities added dozens of new charges against the brothers and Romanian prosecutors have alleged organized crime and trafficking involving dozens of victims.
Prosecutors Ask Court To Keep Andrew and Tristan Tate Detained During Extradition, Citing Their Social Media Posts
Prosecutors also rebuffed the Tates' claims they do not have access to commissary while in jail, including a receipt of their orders in a court filing. (Photo by Andrei Pungovschi/Getty Images)
Federal prosecutors asked a Miami federal court to keep Andrew and Tristan Tate in custody while U.S. authorities process an extradition request that could send the brothers back to the United Kingdom to face dozens of additional criminal charges.
Government’s Argument
In a Monday filing, prosecutors argued the Tates are flight risks and a danger to the community, pointing to a series of social media posts in which the brothers allegedly boast about using multiple travel documents under false names. The filing cites a video attributed to Andrew Tate in which he claims to possess "seven passports" and "15 driver's licenses," saying he would "pull out a license from some random country" if stopped by police to conceal his identity. Prosecutors also pointed to posts in which Andrew called the United Kingdom "a joke," declared he was "never getting extradited," and repeatedly suggested he is "above the law."
"The Court need not look much further than the Tates' own social media posts to understand the great lengths they have gone to avoid detection by government," prosecutors wrote.
Detention Conditions And Rebuttal
Andrew Tate has posted complaints on social media about conditions in the special housing unit, claiming limited commissary access, no phone calls and no outdoor time. Prosecutors disputed those claims in the filing, describing the brothers as having "adequate sleeping arrangements; food and access to water; the ability to order and obtain basic and extra supplies; recreation time; the opportunity to receive social visits; access to phone calls; and the opportunity to visit with their attorneys, often twice a day." As evidence, the government attached commissary receipts dated Aug. 5 showing each brother ordered multiple items such as chips, ramen, coffee, candy and toiletries. The filing further states the Tates are regularly allowed out of their cells for recreation and joint attorney meetings.
Tate defense attorney Joe McBride has told outlets that Andrew's public posts are recorded by legal staff during meetings and published on his behalf, and that Tate is not filming himself while in custody.
Allegations And Extradition Context
The prosecutors emphasized the seriousness of the allegations as a reason to deny release. British authorities recently added dozens of charges: prosecutors say Andrew faces 32 new counts and Tristan six, augmenting roughly 21 combined charges they previously faced in the U.K. According to the filing, Andrew's newly reported charges include seven counts of rape, three counts of human trafficking, three counts of assault and 19 counts tied to child and extreme pornography. Tristan reportedly faces one count of sexual assault, two counts of rape and three trafficking counts.
Separately, Romanian investigators have alleged the brothers participated in organized crime and human trafficking, including trafficking of minors, involving some 46 alleged victims between 2014 and 2022, according to the U.S. prosecutors' filing.
Political And Administrative Notes
The White House has declined to intervene in the extradition process; press secretary Karoline Leavitt responded in July, "No. We've already answered that question." Extradition requests ultimately require approval by the Secretary of State. When asked last month, Secretary of State Marco Rubio said there is "no role for us to play at this moment." Supporters in the Trump orbit have previously voiced backing for the Tates, including public comments from Donald Trump Jr.
Next Steps
The Miami court will consider the government's motion as part of the ongoing extradition proceedings. If the court orders detention to continue, the extradition process and related hearings will proceed under current custody conditions.
Help us improve.
