Convicted defendant Bryan Kohberger filed a late‑July petition seeking to withdraw his 2025 guilty plea in the killings of four University of Idaho students, alleging ineffective counsel and a misleading plea deal. His public statement accuses his lawyers of failing to test the prosecution's case and calls the state's narrative a "work of fiction." The move has energized a largely female online network of supporters, led by a content creator known as Phoenix, while experts note some fans' behavior resembles hybristophilia. Whether the court will allow the plea to be vacated and a trial to proceed remains unclear.
Bryan Kohberger Seeks To Retract Guilty Plea — Female Supporters Say They "Were Waiting"
MEGA
Convicted defendant Bryan Kohberger has filed a late-July petition asking a court to withdraw the guilty plea he entered in 2025 in the slayings of four University of Idaho students. The motion, accompanied by a public statement distributed to The New York Times, accuses his former defense team of providing ineffective assistance and claims he was misled into accepting a plea that exchanged the possibility of the death penalty for four consecutive life terms.
ZUMAPRESS.com / MEGA
Case Background
In 2025 Kohberger pleaded guilty to the killings of Madison Mogen, 21; Kaylee Goncalves, 21; Xana Kernodle, 20; and Ethan Chapin, 20. In his new petition he argues that critical evidence and legal challenges were not pursued by his attorneys, and that the plea was the result of "blatant disinformation." He calls the state's reconstruction of events a "myopic narrative" and a "work of fiction," and says justice cannot be served unless the plea is vacated and the case is reopened.
Ada County Sheriff's Office/MEGA
Online Response And The Role Of Female Supporters
The filing quickly reignited a vocal online movement, much of it led by women. A prominent advocate who uses the pseudonym Phoenix told the Daily Mail that she and many in the true-crime community had anticipated Kohberger's effort to retract the plea and had been closely following court filings, expert affidavits, DNA exhibits, timelines and hearing transcripts.
ZUMAPRESS.com / MEGA
"It wasn't a surprise to many of us. I don't think any of us were really shocked. We were waiting for it," Phoenix said. "I've been following it since day one ... and I realized, this dude is probably innocent."
Phoenix, a creator active on YouTube and TikTok with roughly 50,000 followers, runs a website called JusticeFourAll.com that aggregates documents, photos and transcripts related to the case. Beyond individual creators, dozens of Facebook groups and pages — some with thousands of members — promote scrutiny of the evidence and call for reconsideration of the plea.
Latah County Jail/MEGA
Public Behavior And Expert Views
Some supporters have posted emotional or romantic messages online; media reports cite one Kentucky resident, identified as Brittney Hislope, who described feeling "lovesick" over Kohberger. Criminologist David Wilson told the Daily Mail that the behavior of certain admirers fits a known psychological pattern called hybristophilia, an attraction to people accused of serious crimes. Advocates like Phoenix reject that label for their work, saying their motivation is to ensure transparency and a full airing of evidence.
ZUMAPRESS.com / MEGA
Kohberger's Legal Claims
In court filings Kohberger alleges his lawyers failed to test the state's core theories and did not meaningfully challenge critical pieces of evidence. He asserts an "absolute claim of innocence" and asks the court to permit withdrawal of the plea so the fairness of the process and the evidentiary record can be litigated.
What Comes Next
Whether a judge will allow the plea to be withdrawn and permit a trial remains uncertain. The filing has sharpened debate between prosecutors, who view the existing record as proof of guilt, and a vocal subset of online supporters who say unanswered questions and alleged legal failings justify renewed scrutiny.
Help us improve.
