Andrew Coates, a 22-year-old volunteer firefighter and licensed EMT in Nebraska, was denied a paid firefighter job in Fremont because his diploma indicated he was homeschooled. After the rejection, the city updated the job posting to require graduation from an "accredited high school," prompting an appeal that centered on the posting's ambiguity. Fremont's Civil Service Commission found procedural ambiguity but said it could not override city hiring policy, leaving the denial in place and the family with the option to pursue legal action.
Nebraska Volunteer Firefighter Denied Paid Job Over Homeschool Diploma — City Later Adds "Accredited" Requirement
Image Credit: First Alert 6 / YouTube.
A 22-year-old Nebraska volunteer firefighter says one line on his diploma blocked his path to a paid firefighting job — and prompted a dispute over whether homeschool credentials receive equal treatment.
What Happened
Andrew Coates, a volunteer with the Cedar Bluffs Fire Department who also holds a Nebraska EMT license, applied in April for a paid firefighter position with the City of Fremont. City officials rejected his application after determining his credential indicated he was homeschooled. Shortly after the rejection, Fremont updated the job posting to require graduation from an "accredited high school."
Why Accreditation Matters
Fremont Human Resources Director Jennifer McDuffee told WOWT that accreditation was implicitly part of the original requirement: "I would say it's a standard understanding that when someone requests a high school diploma or GED, they're asking for an accredited diploma." In Nebraska, homeschooling is governed differently: the state classifies homeschools as "exempt schools," which are treated as non-approved, non-accredited private schools under Nebraska Department of Education rules.
Legal And Procedural Issues
Under Neb. Rev. Stat. 79-201, completion of an exempt-school program is recognized separately from graduation through the state's accredited system. That statute relates to compulsory attendance rather than municipal hiring policy, but it underscores the legal distinction at the center of the dispute.
Appeal And Hearing
Coates appealed the rejection to the Fremont Civil Service Commission. The commission's hearing — attended by about 30 homeschool supporters and lasting roughly five hours with legal representation for Coates — focused on whether the original job posting was ambiguous because it did not specify accreditation.
"I don't think there was any discrimination against him," Commissioner Doug Backens said during the hearing. Commission Chair Steve Tellatin pointed to the ambiguity in the posting as a problem.
Ultimately, the commission concluded it did not have authority to change city hiring policy and took no action to overturn the rejection; that left the denial in place and gave the Coates family 30 days to pursue legal action if they chose.
Where Things Stand
Coates and his supporters say the dispute has become about broader access for homeschool graduates, not just one application. Cedar Bluffs Fire Chief Chris Lichtenberg argued Coates is qualified based on his volunteer experience and EMT license. Coates said he still hopes another paid department will value his experience: "To do this job for a living, that would be the dream."
Key dates: Application denied in April; Civil Service Commission heard the appeal on Sept. 18 and declined to intervene.
Help us improve.
