At a Pennsylvania rally, Donald Trump defended his record but made an unscripted appeal to consumers to "give up certain products," citing pencils and saying children do not need "37 dolls." The remarks, delivered in a casino, drew comparisons to Jimmy Carter’s 1970s call for consumer restraint and were criticized for their timing ahead of the holidays. Critics also highlighted a perceived disconnect between the president’s request for public sacrifice and reports of his continued personal luxuries.
Trump Tells Americans To ‘Give Up Certain Products’ Amid Cost‑Of‑Living Backlash

Donald Trump, facing falling approval ratings tied to public frustration over the economy, used a Pennsylvania rally to defend his record — but instead delivered an unscripted message that many viewed as out of touch.
The event, held in a casino, was meant to showcase his economic accomplishments. Rather than laying out new policy proposals, the president returned to off‑the‑cuff remarks about trade and veered into provocative comments about immigrants, wind turbines and transgender people, drawing criticism that the venue and tone were ill chosen.
In a portion of his remarks about trade policy, Trump suggested Americans accept smaller purchases to cope with rising prices. He said:
"You know, you can give up certain products. You can give up pencils. ... You always need steel. You don’t need 37 dolls for your daughter — two or three is nice, but you don’t need 37 dolls."
Rather than proposing concrete economic measures, the president’s remarks encouraged consumers to pare back spending — a message critics compared to former President Jimmy Carter’s 1970s exhortation to turn down thermostats and wear sweaters during an energy crisis.
Observers noted a striking contrast between Trump’s appeal for public sacrifice and reports of his continued personal comforts and projects: work on a new marble bathroom at the White House, plans for an expanded ballroom labeled unnecessary by critics, and frequent trips to Florida where he visits his private club and entertains wealthy guests.
The comments landed just weeks before Christmas and prompted critics to question both the timing and the optics of urging families to buy less while the president remains associated with luxury and leisure.
Source: Originally published by MS NOW.
Similar Articles

Trump’s Rally Energizes MAGA But Exposes Messaging Weakness on Affordability
President Trump’s Pennsylvania rally energized his MAGA supporters but exposed a communications gap on affordability after he...

Trump To Test 'Affordability' Message At Mount Pocono Rally As Economic Confidence Wanes
President Trump will press an "affordability" message at a Mount Pocono rally as the White House seeks to rebuild public conf...

MAGA Asceticism: Trump Urges Thrift as Tariffs and Screening Policies Stir Economic and Civil-Liberty Concerns
Donald Trump urged voters to cope with high prices by cutting nonessential purchases while insisting prices have fallen from ...

Trump Confronts Biden‑Era Price Problem as Americans Grow Frustrated
Overview: President Trump campaigned to roll back the steep price increases of the previous administration, but many consumer...

Trump Calls Affordability a 'Con Job' and Dismisses Cost-of-Living Concerns
President Trump has downplayed public worries about affordability since the 2025 elections, calling the issue a "con job" and...

James Carville Calls Trump a “Loser,” Says His Winning Streak Is Over After Pennsylvania Rally
James Carville told listeners on the Politics War Room podcast that President Trump is "losing everywhere" and called him a "...

Trump Faces Biden-Style Backlash on Affordability as Polls Slide
President Trump has claimed prices are falling, but the September Consumer Price Index rose 0.3%. An AP–NORC poll shows Trump...

Trump Ramps Up Affordability Push, Rolls Back Fuel Rules as Voters Voice Cost Concerns
President Trump announced plans to roll back Biden-era fuel-efficiency rules, saying the change will help lower new-car price...

Trump Approval Inches Up to 41% as Republicans Warm to Cost‑of‑Living Push
New Reuters/Ipsos polling shows President Donald Trump's approval rose to 41% from 38%, coinciding with stronger Republican s...

Trump’s Biggest Test on the Economy and Health Care: Confronting the Affordability Crisis
President Trump faces pressure to address rising costs for health care, groceries and housing as Congress considers whether t...

New POLITICO Poll: Nearly Half Of Americans Struggling To Afford Essentials — Political Fallout Looms
Summary: A POLITICO poll by Public First finds nearly half of Americans struggling to afford essentials such as food, housing...

Trump Dismisses Affordability Concerns as Polls Slide — Calls 'Affordability' His New Focus
At the U.S.-Saudi Investment Forum, President Trump downplayed affordability and cost-of-living worries despite slipping poll...

Trump’s Default Playbook: Blame Biden — Why the President Keeps Pointing Backward
Overview: President Trump has made blaming Joe Biden a central political strategy, linking a wide array of problems — from th...

Inside Scoop: Trump Calls Economy A+++++ — 63% Of Voters Disagree; GOP Women Push Back
Bottom line: President Trump calls the economy "A+++++," but 63% of registered voters disagree. While the administration cite...

Fact Check: Trump’s Pennsylvania Remarks On Inflation, Immigration And Other Claims
Bottom Line: Donald Trump’s Pennsylvania address—promoted as a speech on affordability—repeated multiple misleading or false ...
